Don't they look like they're having a good time?
- Andrew Lam Man Cheung, director and scriptwriter
-
Starring: Louis Cheung, Bob Lam, Ivana Wong, Andrew Lam, Richard Ng,
Lam Suet, Teddy Robin Kwan, Tien Niu, Sammo Hung, Bruce Leung
Last week,
the Hong Kong Film Awards nominations list for this year
was announced. Among its best director nominees were -- deservedly to
my mind -- two first-time directors who also were nominated in the best
scriptwriter as well as best new director categories. That same week, I
viewed a Chinese New Year movie helmed by a debutant helmer. But if
A Lifetime Treasure's Andrew Lam follows in the footsteps of
Still Human's Oliver Chan Siu Kuen and
Men on the Dragon's
Sunny Chan and gets nominated next year in even one of those awards
categories, it'll be a sign that 2019 would have been a thoroughly
terrible year for Hong Kong cinema!
Put
another way: After viewing this mess of a movie, I would be perfectly
happy if Andrew Lam never were to script or direct another film again.
And whatever enjoyment I got from viewing this cinematic work whose
apparently sincere message about it being good to care for, and not
under-value the contributions of, the elderly got inadvertently
sabotaged by its muddled execution I'll largely credit to its capable
but often mis-used cast, a number of whom are respected veteran industry
doyens who really deserved better (along with this effort's audience).
With
the exception of Andrew Lam (who appears on screen as the caring but
eccentric owner of the nursing home), that younger quintet actually
manage to do good work -- and get a few laughs -- with the material they
were given. Ivana Wong is perkily lovable as the facility's sole
nurse. Louis Cheung and Bob Lam manage to inject humanity into their
characters: that of two low-level lackeys sent by a kooky gangster
(portrayed by Lam Suet) to sabotage things there to the point where
control of it will be lost to him. And Lam Suet chews the scene with
obvious relish in a bigger role accorded to him than he usually gets to
play in
Milkyway Image productions, be they crime dramas or romantic comedies.
The
problem lies though in the film being filled with childish attempts at humor
that were old even by the 1990s, if not the 1980s, and seeming conceived
for people with low IQs (and very possibly by people whose EQ and IQs
are both not at all that high a level). Alternatively put: A Lifetime Treasure
is the kind of movie whose high point may well be the scenes involving
several of its main characters taking part in the filming of a cheap
movie featuring a scantily-clad starlet and extras told to pretend to be
zombies who go attack her enmasse when she's bathing out in the open in
an expensive bathtub. As for its low points: well, there are too many
to list; and there's the rub!
Suffice
to state that, among other things, I really didn't appreciate seeing
Sammo Hung playing an idiot for much of the movie (and yes, I know
he's done it in other films -- but that makes this even worse!) and Bruce Leung play a mute for an even greater portion of
A Lifetime Treasure;
and in fact, I found it downright unbecoming and stupidly wasteful of
these two Hong Kong cinema legends' talents. I also didn't like that
there are cheap attempts at visual gags involving people wearing
uniforms clearly ripped off from
Star Trek for no reason other
than they're recognizable pop culture items and icky ones where people
throwing up or losing control of their bodily functions thrown in to try
to increase the laughter quotient.
So,
while it was nice to see screen legends -- including a couple who
haven't appeared on a big screen for several years -- gracing a cinematic
offering again, I really wish that it had been in a better movie.
Similarly, while the likes of Louis Cheung, Bob Lam and Lam Suet may
lack movie star looks, I think they actually did show in A Lifetime Treasure that they too are talents deserving of better platforms -- and maybe to be treasured too!
My rating for this film: 5.0