Red leaves and critter spottings at the Hong Kong Wetland Park :) (Photo-essay)

I'm loath to have my final post of 2022 be a depressing one.  So here's going ahead and sharing some photos from my most recent excursion to the Hong Kong Wetland Park along with the following (true) story: On my most recent visit to this Tin Shui Wai facility before this one a few years ago, I encountered a larger number than previously of loud Mainland Chinese/Putonghua-speakers and, perhaps coincidentally, fewer birds.  There also was construction going on nearby and I got to worrying that the wildlife that was free to go as they please would stop visiting the area.  

Fast forward to this week's visit; with my first impressions being one of shock at how many more residences and shops there now were nearby; with work on the first phase of Wetland Seasons Park having completed earlier this year.  Also, even while the Hong Kong-Mainland China border has yet to fully reopen (though that is due to happen very soon), this was the first I had to queue for several minutes to buy admissions ticket to the Hong Kong Wetland Park!

 

Still, a few minutes after I got into its grounds, I was able to get away for the most part from the crowds.  And best of all: this 2022 visit may well be my best yet for bird watching; with my seeing a great many more birds than I remembered doing so on my most recent visit before this one as well as quite a variety!  So my fears about the birds staying away from the area look to be unfounded, and maybe nature -- and the world in general -- is more resilient than we realize... :)

 

Pui Pui, the saltwater crocodile that is the Hong Kong

Wetland Park's most famous resident

 

This clump of red-leaved trees appeared to be the Hong Kong 

Wetland Park's biggest attraction this time around!

 

While many cameras were trained at the red leaves, I think

 mine was the only trained at the water lilies in the nearby pond ;b

 

Lots of great cormorant spottings to be had at the park :b

 

Lookit the long legs on the black-winged stilt!
 

The easily recognizable black-faced spoonbills 

and one gray heron in the mix for good measure :)

 

I don't know the name of this bird because I couldn't

find a picture of a member of its species on the

Hong Kong Wetland Park website! :O

 

The critter I was most excited to have spotted (and on

a red leaf, no less!): some kind of mantis whose face

I think cartoonishly cute! :b

And for the last time in 2022: Hong Kong is really beautiful, and I still really f**king love this place I call home!

China's National People's Congress Standing Committee deals a death blow to Hong Kong judicial independence

 

Sign spotted in the city this month (I get the feeling

the cleaners tried to erase it but weren't wholly successful)

 

In late November, Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee indicated that he'd ask the China’s top lawmaking body to decide if overseas lawyers could be blocked from taking cases involving the national security law that China imposed on the city back on June 30th, 2020.  Today, the National People’s Congress Standing Committee (NPCSC) issued its decision that Hong Kong’s Chief Executive should now decide whether overseas lawyers working on cases involving the sweeping national security law would pose a threat to national security.   

 

On the face of it, the NPCSC's intepretion can look like China is affirming the "One country, two systems"; something that would be a welcome move.  But, as more than one legal expert has already pointed out, what's in fact happened is further damaging to the rule of law and concept of an independent judiciary in Hong Kong.

 

Lawyer Kevin Yam wrote quite the Twitter thread on this which began as follows: "The NPCSC interpretation goes well beyond just the relatively narrow (but already worrying) issue of whether foreign lawyers can represent parties in Hong Kong [national security law] cases."  Among other things, this interpretation makes it so that "both the Hong Kong [Chief Executive] and the [National Security] Commission can now intervene and override the [Hong Kong] court at any time, and their decisions and acts would not be subject to any judicial review or any other form of legal challenge or oversight."

 

And "it gets worse. Given that[ Hong Kong's National Security] Commission has plenary, unchecked powers to decide what is or isn’t NatSec, and make decisions in relation to the same, such powers can go beyond NatSec litigation or any litigation. It can touch on any policy area."  Consider this: "If [the Hong Kong] NatSec Commission decides that any policy or laws involving regulation of lawyers, pandemic prevention, education, financial regulation, or anything else involves NatSec, it can take action as it pleases with no judicial, legislative or executive oversight."  

 

"As such, this NPCSC interpretation does not merely destroy the authority of [Hong Kong's] courts, but it destroys the entire integrity of the [Hong Kong] legal system, effectively allowing the Chief Executive (in litigation) and [the National Security] Commission (generally) to rule by decree"!  And you don't have to just take Kevin Yam's word on it.  Consider this by legal scholar Eric Yan-ho Lai of Georgetown University: "Now, the National Security Committee can trump all judicial decisions". 

 

More from Eric Lai: Beijing's "interpretation today creates a de facto Political-Legal Committee for Hong Kong: judicial independence vanishes when the executive authorities can override court decision without being challenged by judicial review".  And even a lay person like me can see that when judicial independence is no more, the courts are inevitably going to just hand in decisions that will please Hong Kong's executive body: meaning every national security ruling will be in favor of government prosecutors; with everybody who is charged with having committed a national security law crime inevitably being found guilty and never ever being found to be innocent.  

 

Eric Lai was moved to make a scary and damning analogy:  "Theoretically, the [national security law] interpretation today creates a de facto Prerogative State like what Germany had in the 1930s, when national security authorities enjoys privileges to adjudicate political trials whereas local courts operated in parallel to handle other disputes."  And as we know, Germany in the 1930s was not a good place.  

 

Even before today's ruling, it wasn't as though national security law-era Hong Kong was a good place for lawyers and others seeking for justice to be served.  In the past 24 hours or so, a Reuters piece about Hong Kong human rights lawyers fleeing abroad amid an effort to cleanse the city of dissent has been circulated on Twitter by the likes of Kevin Yam (who was interviewed for it) and Samuel Bickett -- two lawyers who used to live and work in Hong Kong but now most reluctantly don't.  The following excerpt from this lengthy investigative piece written by four journalists should give a sense of Hong Kong's serious legal brain drain: 

Facing or fearing prosecution under the law, or concerned about threats to Hong Kong’s freedoms, many lawyers and legal academics have quietly departed, mostly to Britain, Australia and North America. 

One Hong Kong solicitor who has relocated to England told Reuters that she knew of at least 80 Hong Kong lawyers who had moved to Britain since the security law was imposed in June 2020. Another lawyer, now living in Australia, estimated that several dozen Hong Kong lawyers had moved there.

Some are preparing for the possibility they may never return. Kevin Yam, a commercial solicitor and now vocal critic of Beijing’s crackdown in Hong Kong, said he took his mother’s ashes with him when he departed for Melbourne in April. “I wanted to be fully prepared, given the way Hong Kong is going,” Yam said. “If I couldn’t ever get back to Hong Kong, I didn’t want to leave her there.”

And the following excerpt -- about what former legal constituency represenative Dennis Kwok endured before leaving in November 2020 -- should explain why these lawyers have decided to leave Hong Kong, many for good:

In mid-2020, Kwok found GPS tracking devices under his car “twice in one week,” he said. He provided Reuters with a picture of one of the devices – a small, black rectangular case containing a SIM card to relay positioning data to another device.

Threats were delivered to his office, he said. On one occasion, Chinese “funeral money,” fake paper money sometimes burned by the graveside in a folk tradition, was sent to his office with a note, Kwok recalled. “‘You will be needing these very soon,’ the note read,” he said.

In November 2020, Kwok and three other pro-democracy lawmakers were ousted from the Legislative Council after China’s [legislative body] ruled that sitting members could be disqualified if deemed a threat to national security. That month, Kwok quietly slipped out of Hong Kong. He said articles in the pro-Beijing press, calling for his arrest and accusing him of being a foreign agent, also spurred him to leave

“After they disqualified me,” he said of the... move to oust him, “it was very clear the writing was on the wall.”

And now, the writing looks to be very much on the wall for Hong Kong's legal system as a whole, not just the city's remaining lawyers working to defend pro-democracy activists and other people who want justice to be served.  This even when they are themselves not behind bars -- unlike, say, Chow Hang-tung -- and defendants in cases rather than just the legal counsel -- again, like with Chow Hang-tung but also the likes of Martin Lee and Margaret Ng.

Hong Kong will do away with many pandemic regulations and restrictions tomorrow but this doesn't mean that normality is anywhere in sight still!

Come tomorrow, banners like this will not be 

blotting the Hong Kong landscape anymore!

 

Today saw Hong Kong record 20,865 new Covid cases and 59 new Covid deaths.  The 30 day trend for new Covid cases, deaths and hospital admissions continues to rise.  And yet today also saw the Hong Kong government announce that, as of tomorrow (Thursday, December 29th), most of the still existing pandemic regulations and restrictions will be dropped!  In the words of the BBC: "It is a dramatic move by the city, which once had some of the toughest restrictions in the world."

 

With regards to specifics, a Hong Kong Free Press piece outlines that: "Hong Kong is to scrap its Covid Vaccine Pass scheme, Chief Executive John Lee has announced on Wednesday, meaning proof of vaccination will no longer be required to enter key venues. Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) tests for international arrivals will be scrapped, though unvaccinated non-residents will still be denied entry.  The health authorities will also stop requiring close contacts of Covid-19 patients to undergo isolation, will axe the group gathering limit of 12 people and lift venue capacity limits"!

 

Hong Kong's move follows in the wake of China's decision to abandon its Zero Covid strategy (presumably because it was failing). And while there are undoubtedly people who hail it, others are less pleased -- including respiratory medicine specialist Leung Chi-chi.  "The medical system could be overburdened as Hong Kong still sees the trend of daily confirmed cases at a high level under the winter season," he's stated.  In addition, he's suggested "that travellers from the mainland to Hong Kong should be required to have received at least two doses of vaccination to reduce the potential infection risks."

 

Frankly, if many Hong Kongers had their way, the border between Hong Kong and Mainland China will be sealed off, not opened widely.  But that's not going to happen.  Despite cases roaring in Mainland China, Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee announced on Christmas Eve (last Saturday) that by mid-January, Hong Kong’s border with the mainland would reopen.  And the scrapping of the vaccine pass and a number of other restrictions slated to take place from tomorrow appear designed to smooth the movement of Mainland Chinese people not only into Hong Kong but, also, while they are in Hong Kong!

 

Something worth noting: Hong Kong is still refusing to "lie flat" by keeping some pandemic rules and regulations.  Measures that will remain in place even after today include "the mask mandate, isolation orders for Covid patients, daily rapid testing for students and teachers, a ban on unvaccinated international arrivals, and a ban on eating on ferries."  As Hong Kong Free Press chief editor Tom Grundy noted in a Tweet: Hong Kong still "is definitely not 'back to normal"".  And that's not even taking into account the continued existence of the draconian national security law that China imposed on the territory back on June 30th, 2020.

 

Something that makes the situation in Hong Kong particularly abnormal: even while it has a pandemic mask (wearing) mandate, it also has a mask ban on the books.  A reminder:back in October 2019, then Chief Executive Carrie Lam invoked emergency powers to introduce a Face Covering Regulation targetted at pro-democracy protestors.  When I first heard of it, I called it another disastrous proposed piece of legislation.  Now I think of it as frankly ludicruous.  

 

But for the Hong Kong government, it of course has the purpose of providing a legal basis for punishing protestors and dissuading protests.  As now overseas based journalist, Kris Cheng, Tweeted this afternoon: "So in Hong Kong there will be no more quarantine order, vaccine pass, and all social distancing measures except mask mandate. That means peaceful protests are fine now if you wear a mask? oh wait the anti-mask law for protests is still in place…"

Seasons greetings, and a tourism plus pandemic update!

 

Another photo taken while out hiking last week

 

Many people have been taking advantage of the beautiful weather and long (Christmas-Boxing Day) holiday weekend to venture out to various parts of Hong Kong in recent days, and sharing their photos showing that Hong Kong is really beautiful.  Ironically, tourism sector lawmaker Perry Yiu Pak-leung also chose this past weekend to assert that "the charm of Hong Kong as a single destination is limited" -- and thus should be marketed as a twin destination along with Macau for "great synergy".

 

I'm not going to deny that Macau is not without any charms (and I do miss my once annual trips to the former Portugese enclave that used to be a convenient one hour ferry ride away).  But there's no way I believe that it's got more to offer to tourists and travellers than Hong Kong; this not least since the 118 square kilometer sized territory is dwarfed by 1,118 square kilometer Hong Kong!

 

And while it's true that Hong Kong has not had many visitors in recent years, that's due far more to Hong Kong's harsh pandemic rules and regulations -- which remain more restrictive than anything to be found in pretty much the rest of the world, especially now that Mainland China suddenly abandoned its Zero Covid ways a few weeks ago -- and the scary national security law that China imposed on it on June 30th, 2020!    

 

In addition, something that wasn't helping make Hong Kong attractive to non-Mainland Chinese tourists as well as negatively affected Hong Kongers' quality of life for several years leading up to 2020 was the vast numbers of Mainland Chinese visitors that were regularly flooding into Hong Kong (peaking at 51.04 million in 2018).  And I have to say that one of the greatest boons of the pandemic has been how much less crowded many areas of Hong Kong -- including Tsim Sha Tsui (which is home to the greatest density of hotels in Hong Kong), Mongkok (a popular shopping area) and Causeway Bay (another major shopping area) -- have been and, consequently, a greater pleasure to stroll around than previously was the case.

 

So I'd think that many Hong Kongers are absolutely not looking forward to the Hong Kong-Mainland China border reopening any time soon.  And of course this feeling is exacerbated by China currently experiencing a Covid outbreak so massive -- as in possibly 250 million people being infected in December alone! -- that it's caused the Zero Covid policy to fail spectacularly and China's top health body to stop publishing daily Covid figures (be it from shame -- since it's been estimated that the country could see as many as 1 million pandemic deaths -- or because things are so out of control that they no longer can get any reliable figures).

 

It's not just the thought of many infected people flooding into Hong Kong from Mainland China.  Rather, it's also the fear that they will overwhelm Hong Kong's health services and such.  (Something which won't be all that difficult to do since there already were concerns expressed late last week by public hospital chief Tony Ko about emergency rooms being inundated and long waiting times over the holiday period.  Oh, and the overall occupancy of medical beds in acute hospitals is currently at around 112 per cent!)

 

It really did not assure Hong Kongers that early last week, as former Hong Kong pro-democracy legislative councillor Charles Mok reported, "Mainland residents are told by Fosun Pharma, distributor of Pfizer-BioNTech's Covid vaccines in greater China region, that they can go to Hong Kong to get the bivalent vaccine."  Also, last Tuesday, the Hong Kong government announced that all of Hong Kong’s available Covid vaccines (CoronaVac, the BioNTech monovalent, and the BioNTech bivalent) were now registered as pharmaceutical products and, as such, no longer required emergency use authorization by the Secretary of Health -- paving the way for "an inevitable onslaught of mainlanders coming to the city for mRNA vaccines" which have not been available to them over in Mainland China.

 

In anticipation of this, there have been calls -- including by a University of Hong Kong virologist and the head of a Hong Kong pharmacists' group -- on the authorities "to consider charging non-residents for Covid vaccinations here".  The president of The Society of Hospital Pharmacists, William Chu, also warned that "free jabs and treatments could prompt too many to cross the border to access medical services here and burden the local system.  "People from mainland China demand for more symptomatic relief medications," he said. "They may go to Hong Kong to get more medications. At the moment they are looking for medications on the mainland but the supply is very limited.""

 

Already, there have been reports galore of Hong Kong pharmacies having run out of Panadol and related medicines thanks to people snapping them out to send to their relatives and friends in Mainland China.  I hate to say this but the sight of empty shelves is leading to talk of "locusts" again.  And, at the very least, it's adding to the fears and repulsion people have at the thought of Mainland Chinese "tourists" -- shoppers, more than anything else, really -- descending on Hong Kong in droves once more.     

We always knew that it would be a case of when, not if, they would return.  Now it's looking very much like it will happen next month, and maybe even early in January.  Ironically, up until the past few weeks, there had been suggestions that many Mainland Chinese people would want to avoid Hong Kong, seeing it as "unclean" and "tainted" (since Hong Kong's "Zero Covid" has long been more like "Dynamic Zero" rather than completely in step with what was implemented on the other side of the Hong Kong-Mainland China border).  

 

A reminder: Hong Kong's Covid numbers have been at five figures with regards to daily new cases for some time; with 18,533 reported for today alone.  Also, the daily critical, ICU and death figures have been on the rise since October.  So, yeah, the pandemic is most certainly not over -- in Hong Kong, Mainland China and the world over.  And the only reason why I don't mention Hong Kong's Covid numbers and situation as a factor in terms of attracting or detracting tourism is because Covid is rampant everywhere and people in many territories have just decided to "live with the virus"!  

The Narrow Road centres on -- and is anchored by -- an ordinary hero (Film review)

  

What may be the last Hong Kong film I'll view in 2022

 

The Narrow Road (Hong Kong, 2022)

- Lam Sum, director

- Starring: Louis Cheung, Angela Yuen, Tung On-na

 

Not so long ago, a film friend complained to me that the protagonists of contemporary Hong Kong movies tend to be losers rather than heroes.  While I'd accept that many recent Hong Kong movies have had main characters who are neither super heroic nor larger than life, I still think that they can be classified as ordinary heroes: people who manfully make the best of bad situations, and show their humanity along the way.  That description fits the protagonists of such as Still Human (2018),  Zero to Hero (2021).  I think also of the main characters of Madalena (2021), a film that shares the same lead actor as The Narrow Road.  

 

Louis Cheung appears to have become the "go to" actor for filmmakers looking for a male star who convinces as a working class Everyman that is a diamond in the rough; this not least in terms of his ability and willingness to care for women whom he sees more good in than they might do so about themselves.  In Lam Sum's The Narrow Road, Cheung plays Chak, the operator of a one man cleaning company which is struggling to make a profit but whose services are increasingly in demand thanks to the ongoing pandemic, as well as the filial son of a mother (portrayed by Petra Au) whose ways of thinking and acting -- including with regards to wanting to reuse surgical masks and thinking she's going to win big at the lottery or with a bet on a horse -- Hong Kongers will find all too alternately amusing and frustratingly familiar.

 

With his workload increasing and his back aching, Chak decides to hire an assistant.  Enter Candy (played by Angela Yuen), a single mother with no professional cleaning experience but with the requisite energy and, more importantly, willingness to do the job for the low wages that Chak initially offers.  Early on, Candy gives ample indication that she might well prove to be trouble.  But she -- or, maybe, actually, more so her precocious young daughter, Chu (essayed by Tung On-na) -- is charming enough to get the good-hearted Chak caring for both daughter and mother.   

 

If truth be told, I had problems feeling sympathy, never mind empathy, for Candy -- and I'm not entirely sure whether this was intentional.  Also, while there may be some who might think that Chu's cute, I didn't.  On the other hand, I did appreciate that the young girl made many "from out of the mouths of babes" pronouncements that were spot on with regards to what's going on in Hong Kong; including about how many people are leaving Hong Kong, and who are the types of people who are able to do so vis a vis who are staying -- and/or are left -- behind.

 

Alternatively, it's easy enough to feel for Chak, and respect his efforts to do his job properly and professionally, be it cleaning -- and sanitizing or disinfecting -- a gym, medical clinic, cha chaan teng or the home of someone who recently died there.  His life may be a limited one in terms of prospects for upward mobility or even opportunities for luxuries (including going away for a holiday abroad or even dining on Korean barbecue).  But The Narrow Road's emotional anchor appears to take quiet pride in his ability to stay on the straight and narrow path even if he's not entirely certain where it will take him.

 

At the Golden Horse Awards last month, The Narrow Road's Wong Hin-yan came away with the prize for Best Original Film Score.  For my part, I reckon that the film's cinematographer Meteor Cheung deserves kudos, if not an actual award, for his work in crafting evocative visuals: including of a Hong Kong that has fallen on hard times; with many shop fronts shuttered and life taking place in unglamorous surroundings far away from the Central business district that may well feel foreign to many Hong Kongers.

 

It may ostensibly be a drama about a nobody but The Narrow Road says much about the current state of Hong Kong.  Still, lest one think its tale is an entirely downbeat one, remember this about Hong Kongers: they are survivors.  And even while it also does not deny that their home city's future is uncertain, this cinematic offering made by Hong Kongers for Hong Kongers does show them to be so.          

 

My rating for this film: 7.0

Hiking on an alternative route less taken between Mui Wo and the Trappist Monastery pier (Photo-essay)

I went for my first hike in a number of months earlier today which also was my first hike in a while where I wasn't the hike leader.  The friend I was with and I have been on the usual route that goes from Discovery Bay to Mui Wo via the Trappist Monastery several times.  We've also (separately) hiked from Discovery Bay to Mui Wo via Lo Fu Tau.  

 

This time around, my friend took me on a route further to the east of both of those that's not as easy as the former but also no where as difficult as the latter.  There were a couple of uphill sections on this trail -- which also appears to be far less of a beaten track than the others -- that I found on the challenging side (and one where I worried that I had gotten stuck because the next step was just so high up!)  But all ended up being well; with some stupendous views to be had and also an interesting sight involving a fishing folk using an interesting fishing method to get quite the haul near the Trappist Monastery pier that ended up being the hike's end destination (rather than Discovery Bay)!

 

View from the far end of Silver Mine Bay Beach

 

View from an unnamed beach looking back at Silver Mine 

Bay Beach, Mui Wo and the mountains behind them

 

As we ascended up the hills, a view unfolded that 

included the significantly more populated -- but still 

greener than is often realized -- Hong Kong Island

 

I know people who don't like seeing urban scapes when

they are out hiking but for me, this can be a charm

of hiking in Hong Kong! :)

 

Of course, if one wants to focus on greenery,

one can indeed do so when out hiking in Hong Kong :)

 

On this hike, one also could do some boat viewing 

if one's so inclined -- as was the case with me :b

 

Quite the view, especially on a super bright and blue

sky afternoon like today's was!

 

Fishing vessels with people hard at work (and, from 

what I could see, pretty productive work at that!)

A tale of two bars: one now closed; the other of which may still be around but has been negatively affected by the pandemic too

 

My favourite drink at my favorite bar in Hong Kong

often comes with a heart-shaped lemon peel :)

 

For a number of years, my favorite place to hang out and drink in Hong Kong was Sake Bar Ginn.  I'd go there once a week and felt privileged to be counted as a regular there.  Over time, I made a number of friends there who were more than just drinking buddies -- in that we'd often meet up outside of our favorite sake bar as well as over there.      

 

A year or so ago, Sake Bar Ginn closed down.  If truth be told, I haven't missed it much as I stopped going to it more than a year before its Japanese owner decided to call time on not only her establishment but also her time in Hong Kong (due to diminishing economic returns here; thanks in no small part to not only the pandemic but Hong Kong's anti-pandemic measures that have included, for some months, the closing of bars).  

 

One reason for my deciding against spending (much) time there in recent years was that someone who was even more than a regular there than I was was very vocally "blue".  And while I could tolerate his pro-Beijing and -police rantings before June 12th, 2019, I couldn't after that fateful day.  (Ironically, two other Sake Bar Ginn regulars became two of my "protest buddies" -- in that we went on a number of anti-extradition bill-turned-general pro-democracy protest marches and rallies together in 2019 and into 2020.)           

The other reason was that Covid happened -- and for a good part of the pandemic, I've been reluctant to spend time in bars, especially ones located in frequently crowded party areas like Lan Kwai Fong (which Sake Bar Ginn was), where one frequently had to run a veritable gauntlet through upon leaving late at night (and sometimes also when going over there earlier in the evening).  And I have to say that the last time I went to my once favorite bar, before masking became required in Hong Kong, I was put off by being in a small lift with a bunch of unmasked folks, two of whom ended up going into Sake Bar Ginn before me.

 

A measure of how much the pandemic has impacted/changed my lifestyle is that whereas I used to go to bars weekly (and often more than once a week) pre-pandemic, I can count on my two hands the number of times I've been to an actual bar in the past two years (and pubs not at all).  And all of my bar visits have actually been to only one drinking establishment: located in a building where it is the only establishment of its kind there, in an area that's associated far more with other activities besides drinking.  

This particular bar has been around for years and has built up a loyal clientele.  But in recent years, it's suffered from a significant loss of business.  One reason is that many of its Japanese clients (it's another bar owned and operated by a Japanese national) decided to leave Hong Kong -- or were sent back home by their companies.  Something else that also negatively affected its business is the reluctance of many people -- like me -- to go to bars during the pandemic.

 

And this particularly so after the government introduced a strange extra requirement for bars that have bar licenses (as opposed to restaurant or cafe licenses -- something that a number of (primarily) drinking establishments rushed to do in the past year or so) in June of this year: namely, that customers would have to take a Rapid Antigen Test (RAT) within 24 hours prior to entering a bar and show that they had a negative result from it.  This on top of being required to use the Leave Home Safe trac(k)ing app and show proof of one having been fully vaccinated (something which currently stands at three shots of a Covid vaccine) -- like with restaurants, cafes, cinemas and many other venues.

 

The proprietor of my current favorite Hong Kong bar estimates that his business dropped by 70 percent after this requirement was introduced -- and, for a time, talked of closing down before the end of this year.  Happily (for me and other fans of his cocktails and his bar's extensive selection of whiskies), he and the bar are still around currently -- and I am sure that he'll feel some relief at today's news that, starting from this Thursday, the RAT requirement is to be scrapped. 

Still, one has to wonder: is all this too little too late?  How much extra time has this particular relaxation of an unpopular regulation bought him and his business?  "Addressing reporters at a press conference on Tuesday, Under Secretary for Health Libby Lee said the latest relaxations will come into effect on Thursday. “We hope to have some easing [of policies] but we also have to be careful about the pace,” Lee said."  But while it may sound like she thinks that Hong Kong is the turtle that will eventually win the race (over the rest of the world's hare), my sense is that the rest of the world (including many in Hong Kong) are more inclined to think that the Hong Kong government consists of a bunch of clueless cuckoos than reliable, slow and steady turtles!

In fact, just this morning, the Hong Kong Free Press ran a piece in which a Hong Kong medical expert, microbiologist Ho Pak-leung, sounded like even he had grown impatient and frustrated at what's been going on in the Big Lychee and openly "hoped the government would speed up its return to normalcy."  And while Under Secretary for Health Libby Lee (and her boss, Health Secretary Lo Chung-mau) may think otherwise, Dr Ho has also put it on the record that he reckons that "the city’s authorities should focus on protecting people in need and scrap “ineffective” Covid-19 measures such as testing, isolation and the use of the government’s tracing app LeaveHomeSafe"!

An enjoyable excursion to a revitalised Yim Tin Tsai (Photo-essay)

It's currently cold enough in Hong Kong that I'm wearing a Norwegian sweater (bought when I visited Norway and went on a Hurtigruten cruise back in 2015) and also thermal underwear!  And the temperatures are expected to drop further tomorrow before gradually rising to more comfortable levels once more next week.  The cold weather's also been accompanied by some rain in recent days.  So the friend I went with to Yim Tsin Tsai earlier this week and I count ourselves pretty lucky that the rain only started falling only at the tail end of our excursion to the Sai Kung area island that I had not been to since 2013.   

A lot has changed since my first visit to Yim Tin Tsai.  Among other things, the Occupy phase of the Umbrella Movement happened (in 2014), as did the anti-extradition bill protests of 2019 and China's imposition on a national security law on Hong Kong (on June 30th, 2020).  On a personal note: one of the friends I explored the island with back in 2013 is no longer in Hong Kong (and two others of our party of six that day are due to leave next month).  

Yim Tin Tsai has changed a bit too -- and, it seems, for the better.  For one thing, it doesn't seem to be abandoned anymore.  Also, the scene has been enlivened by such as its playing host to the Sai Kung Hoi Arts Festival (which opened last month and scheduled to go on for three years) whose art installations and cheerful volunteers helped make a cool (temperature-wise) gray day actually enjoyable and metaphorically cool! 

 

View from the back of the boat that took us

 from Sai Kung over to Yim Tin Tsai

 

An early reminder that Yim Tin Tsai is a Christian

(particularly Catholic) settlement

 

The island's chapel (whose size I think of as more like 

that of a church) was closed when I previously visited

 

Happily, I was able to see the inside of St. Joseph's Chapel

this time around, and what an impressive interior it has!

 

Something else I was happy to see: that Yim Tin Tsai's 

salt pans have been resurrected

 

One of the cooler art installations: Joseph Chan's Water Dragon 

-- a (hu)man-powered dragon spine water wheel! 

 

Not an art installation but, instead, the doorway of

an old house that looks like people are planning to 

renovate and live in/re-use at some point in the near future

 

The boat that took my friend and I back to Sai Kung

(sans dog, who looked interested in going on it too) :)

A rare and bittersweet legal victory for lawyer-activist Chow Hang-tung yesterday

A typical June 4th scene in Victoria Park not so long ago

 

Back in early January, lawyer-activist Chow Hang-tung was sentenced to 15 months in prison for incitement for a banned vigil to commemorate those who died in Beijing’s crackdown in Tiananmen Square in 1989.  Yesterday, that conviction was overturned after a court ruled that the Hong Kong police's decision to ban last year's June 4th vigil was unlawful.

"Wearing black and standing before judge Judianna Barnes at the High Court on Wednesday, Chow appeared surprised and joyful when the results of the appeal were handed down.  As court was dismissed, people in the public gallery let out cheers before being told by security guards to quieten down." Thus reported the Hong Kong Free Press (HKFP).

 

It's not that Chow hasn't been maintaining her innocence all along.  But, as an AFP piece noted: "The ruling is a rare rebuke of authorities in a city where the public commemoration of Beijing's deadly 1989 crackdown has been virtually wiped out in recent years."

 

The same AFP piece contains useful contextual information for those who didn't realize, including the following: "Chow, a 37-year-old lawyer and one of Hong Kong's most prominent democracy activists, led a now-disbanded group that used to organise the city's annual candlelight vigils to mourn those killed in Tiananmen Square when China sent troops to crush democracy protests."

 

Also: "Police have banned the last three vigils citing the coronavirus and security fears and the courts have already jailed multiple activists who defied those bans, including Chow"; thus making it so that the last authorized June 4th candlelight vigil allowed in Hong Kong was back in 2019 -- the 30th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square Massacre.  One which hundreds of thousands of people attended.  Indeed, if the vigil organizers (who included Chow) are to be believed: the number of attendees for the 2019 vigil -- which took place just five days before the anti-extradition bill march of June 9th that had 1 million participants -- actually hit a record high. 

 

Quoting the HKFP piece once more: "In a written judgement, [Judge] Barnes said that in banning the vigil, police had not abided by a section in the Public Order Ordinance that states a public meeting should not be prohibited if conditions could be imposed."  Specifically, "Although the organisers of the gathering had said they were willing to abide by any measures set out by [the] police… [the] police did not seriously consider this, and did not raise measures or conditions to be considered such as restricting the time during which people can enter the venue, the number of attendants… a requirement for scanning the [Covid-19 app] LeaveHomeSafe, wearing a mask, a ban on eating, etc., that could control the risk of the virus spreading".

 

The AFP piece sums it up as follows: The police were adjudged to have "wrongly banned the vigil in 2021 as they did not "proactively and seriously consider" ways to faciliate a public gathering, as was required by law.  As the government failed to prove the ban was legally valid, Chow's articles would no longer constitute a crime and her conviction was scrapped on appeal."

 

So a rare victory, then, for not only Chow Hang-tung but rule of law in Hong Kong.  Except that "Despite her court victory, Chow remains in custody as she faces further prosecutions including for national security charges which carry up to a decade in jail."  Also the Department of Justice has expectedly declared it will appeal this decision in a higher court. 

 

Something worth noting too: Judge Judianna Barnes is already 70 years old.  One wonders how long more she -- and judges like her who actually seem to try to make sure that justice is served -- will be presiding over courts and trials in Hong Kong.  Sadly, and contrary to the refrain often chanted by pro-democracy march participants over the year, I fear that time may not be on our side. :S