Monday, November 30, 2020

Thoughts turn once more to the 12 Hong Kongers detained in Shenzhen, Prince Edward MTR station, the Wuhan coronavirus, and Carrie Lam

while on a boat in Hong Kong this past weekend...
 
MTR stations while passing by one last week
 
One hundred days ago today, 12 Hong Kongers sought to journey by boat to seek asylum in Taiwan.  Eleven of them had been facing prosecution in connection with anti-government protests, while one (activist Andy Li) had been arrested, but not charged, under the national security law.  Upon being notified by the Hong Kong police, the Mainland Chinese coastguard swooped in to arrest them.  They have been in custody in Shenzhen ever since.  And considering what we know has happened behind bars in Mainland China, there understandably are fears that they are being ill-treated, even tortured, while awaiting trial; with the letters that the prisoners have sent to their relatives hardly putting people at ease.
 
On Friday, the police in the Yantian district of Shenzhen said they had completed investigations into the case of the 12 Hong Kongers. While 10 members of the group are now accused of entering Mainland Chinese waters illegally, two face a more serious charge of organising the illegal crossingIt remains unclear what the maximum punishment for these charges are.  And it does not help that the lawyers their families who have appointed to defend them have been unable to meet with their clients.  
 
As Causeway Bay Books' Lam Wing-kee -- now in exile in Taiwan -- noted in a recent interview, "You can’t compare custody in Hong Kong to custody in [Mainland] China."  Hence the likes of Joshua Wong (still) seeking to keep attention on the plight of the 12 Hong Kongers behind bars in Shenzhen even when he himself is behind bars, albeit in Hong Kong.  (And while we're at it: spare a thought -- and if you're religiously inclined, prayers -- too for Gui Minhai, the Hong Kong bookseller sentenced to 10 years jail in Mainland China after being abducted in Thailand and despite his being a Swedish citizen.)      
 

At the same time, 伯昏無人's Tweet on the matter sums up how a good number of people feel: "By now the importance of 8/31 doesn't depend on whether anyone actually died that night. We commemorate it as a deplorable milestone in the collapse of HK civil society and the descent of these disgraceful uniformed thugs into a band of parasitical gangsters."  
 
And if I may add to it: we also mourn what we've lost in Hong Kong in the past year and a half or so: what remained of our respect for the police force once known as Asia's finest; the love we used to have for the MTR; and a time before Hong Kong bore comparisons to a police state, with "martial law and military-style rule", and talk and declarations coming seemingly daily about its (impending) demise.
 
 
Carrie Lam being Carrie Lam, she also took the opportunity to dismiss suggestions that the government has reacted too slowly to the current outbreaks, and rejected suggestions that it is to blame for the latest outbreaks which are thought to be linked to infected people returning from overseas.  In addition, she disclosed that the government's mulling setting up a hotline so people can report each other to the authorities for social distancing infringements.   
 
A reminder: earlier this month, the government set up a hotline for people to snitch on their fellow Hong Kongers who they suspect of having broken China's national security law for Hong Kong.  So it seems that it really is intent on encouraging Hong Kongers to become "snitches" and, in so doing, effecting a "Cultural Revolution" in a territory that had been spared the individual and collective suffering and social warping that had occured across the border in Mainland China for much of the 1960s and 1970s.        

No comments: